To the Editor:
Re “The Cap Doesn’t Fit,” by Michelle Mello and Amitabh Chandra:
There is certainly nothing wrong with bringing evidence-based medicine into health care practice. But allowing clinical practice guidelines to become the sole legal standard for deciding negligence is a terrible idea.
First, there are already more than a thousand such guidelines in existence. Not only are some contradictory, but also patient safety could greatly suffer from a “one size fits all” approach, because patients often present widely varying and complicated conditions. Furthermore, conflicts of interest and specialty bias are problems in the development of these guidelines.
The few states that experimented in the 1990s with using guidelines as medical standards, like Florida, failed to garner support among physicians.
Center for Justice and Democracy
Contact CJ&D for a copy of the entire story.